PriceMyDegree Contact
Tax benefits for education 4 sources

American Opportunity Credit vs Lifetime Learning Credit: which education tax credit fits your situation

Two federal tax credits can lower the tax bill for college costs: the American Opportunity Credit and the Lifetime Learning Credit. You cannot take both for the same student in the same year, so the choice matters, and the right answer depends on how far along the student is, what the student is studying, how much was paid out of pocket, and the family's income. This guide compares the two using the IRS rules for tax year 2025, the most recent edition of the IRS instructions we could open, with worked examples labelled as hypothetical so you can see the arithmetic. It is general education and not tax advice.

The short version, for tax year 2025

The American Opportunity Credit, often abbreviated AOTC, is worth up to $2,500 per eligible student, and up to 40 percent of it can be refundable. It is limited to four tax years per student and to students pursuing a degree or other recognized credential who are enrolled at least half time. The Lifetime Learning Credit, often abbreviated LLC, is worth up to $2,000 per tax return, is not refundable, and has no limit on the number of years. It also covers students who are not working toward a degree, such as someone taking a course to acquire or improve job skills.

Both credits use the same income limits for tax year 2025. The credit is reduced when modified adjusted gross income, or MAGI, is between $80,000 and $90,000 for single, head of household and qualifying surviving spouse filers, and between $160,000 and $180,000 for joint filers. At $90,000 or more ($180,000 or more for joint returns) neither credit is available. Neither credit is available to anyone who files as married filing separately, or to a taxpayer who can be claimed as a dependent on someone else's return.

These figures come from IRS Publication 970 and the instructions for Form 8863, both for 2025. Older articles online sometimes show lower Lifetime Learning limits. An archived IRS tip from 2019 that we opened listed $68,000 and $136,000 for the Lifetime Learning Credit, so always check the year printed on any source before you rely on its numbers.

How the American Opportunity Credit is calculated

The credit is 100 percent of the first $2,000 of adjusted qualified education expenses plus 25 percent of the next $2,000. Expenses above $4,000 per student do not increase it, so the most it can reach is $2,000 plus $500, which equals $2,500. Qualified expenses are tuition, required enrollment fees, and course materials the student needs for the course of study. Publication 970 says materials count whether or not they are bought from the school.

The student must be pursuing a degree or other recognized credential and be enrolled at least half time for at least one academic period beginning in 2025, or in the first three months of 2026 if the expenses were paid in 2025. The student must not have completed the first four years of postsecondary education before 2025, and must not have been convicted of a federal or state felony for possessing or distributing a controlled substance by the end of 2025. Publication 970 says the credit can be claimed for only four tax years per student. You generally need Form 1098-T from the school, and the school's employer identification number goes on Form 8863.

Up to 40 percent of the credit can come back as a refund even if you owe no tax, which is the feature that sets the AOTC apart. The Form 8863 instructions also say certain students under age 24 at the end of the year cannot claim the refundable part, depending on conditions about support, parents and filing status that are spelled out in the instructions. The rest of the credit is nonrefundable, meaning it can reduce your tax to zero but no further.

  • Maximum: $2,500 per eligible student; up to 40 percent refundable.
  • Years: four tax years per student, and the student must not have finished four years of postsecondary education before 2025.
  • Student: degree or credential program, at least half time for one academic period.
  • Expenses: tuition, required enrollment fees, and course materials needed for the course.

How the Lifetime Learning Credit is calculated

The credit is 20 percent of up to $10,000 of qualified expenses paid for all eligible students on the return, so the most it can reach is 20 percent of $10,000, which equals $2,000. The $10,000 limit applies to the whole return, not to each student. That is the key structural difference: the AOTC is counted per student, so a family with two eligible students can claim up to $2,500 for each, while the LLC tops out at $2,000 for the entire return.

The course must be part of a postsecondary degree program or taken by the student to acquire or improve job skills. The student does not need to pursue a degree, and there is no limit on the number of years the credit can be claimed. Publication 970 treats books differently from the AOTC: course related books, supplies and equipment count for the LLC only if they must be paid to the school as a condition of enrollment or attendance. The LLC is nonrefundable. Table 3-1 in Publication 970 describes it as limited to the amount of tax you must pay on your taxable income.

  • Maximum: $2,000 per return, which is 20 percent of up to $10,000 of expenses.
  • Years: no limit.
  • Student: no degree requirement; courses to acquire or improve job skills qualify.
  • Refundable: no.

Side by side

Putting the rules next to each other shows which situations favor which credit. All items below are for tax year 2025.

  • Size: AOTC up to $2,500 per student; LLC up to $2,000 per return.
  • Refund: AOTC up to 40 percent refundable; LLC none.
  • Years: AOTC four tax years per student; LLC unlimited.
  • Program: AOTC requires a degree or credential and at least half time enrollment; LLC does not.
  • Books and supplies: AOTC counts materials needed for the course wherever bought; LLC counts them only when paid to the school as a condition of enrollment.
  • Income: both phase out between $80,000 and $90,000 ($160,000 to $180,000 joint) and end at $90,000 ($180,000 joint).
  • Shared exclusions: no married filing separately; not available if you can be claimed as someone else's dependent.

Worked hypothetical: an AOTC claim

Hypothetical illustration only, with no real student or school. A head of household filer with a modified adjusted gross income of $60,000 has a dependent child in the second year of a bachelor's degree, enrolled full time. The parent claims the child as a dependent. During 2025 the family paid $5,000 in tuition, $500 in required fees and $700 for textbooks bought at an off campus store. That is $5,000 plus $500 plus $700, which equals $6,200. A tax-free scholarship of $2,200 was applied to the same expenses.

Tax-free scholarship money reduces qualified expenses. Adjusted qualified expenses are $6,200 minus $2,200, which equals $4,000. The credit is 100 percent of the first $2,000, which is $2,000, plus 25 percent of the next $2,000, which is $500. The total is $2,500. Up to 40 percent can be refundable, and 40 percent of $2,500 is $1,000. The other $1,500 can offset tax owed.

Now suppose the same family's MAGI were $85,000 instead of $60,000. The credit is reduced by a ratio. Form 8863 subtracts MAGI from $90,000, which gives $5,000, and divides by $10,000 for single and head of household filers, which gives 0.5. The reduced credit is $2,500 multiplied by 0.5, which equals $1,250. For a joint return the Form 8863 line uses $180,000 and a $20,000 range instead.

Worked hypothetical: a Lifetime Learning Credit claim

Hypothetical illustration only. A single filer with a MAGI of $55,000, working full time, takes two evening graduate courses in a professional certificate program. She is not pursuing a degree and has already used four years of the AOTC in the past, so the AOTC is not an option. She paid $3,800 in tuition and a $200 required fee, a total of $4,000, with no tax-free assistance. The credit is 20 percent of $4,000, which equals $800.

Compare the same $4,000 of expenses under each credit for a student who qualified for both. The AOTC gives $2,500, as computed above, and the LLC gives $800. This is why a student who qualifies for the AOTC is usually better off claiming it for that year. Now suppose a graduate student who does not qualify for the AOTC has $12,000 of qualified expenses. Only $10,000 counts, so the credit is 20 percent of $10,000, which equals $2,000, not 20 percent of $12,000. The $2,000 of expenses above the limit adds nothing.

Because the LLC is nonrefundable, it helps only if there is tax to reduce. A filer whose tax is $600 after other credits can use at most $600 of an $800 credit, as Publication 970 describes the nonrefundable limit.

Rules that apply to both credits

Several rules catch families who assume the credits work like deductions. You cannot use the same student's expenses for both credits in the same year, although Publication 970 says you can choose a different credit for each student. You also cannot count the same expense twice. A credit cannot be based on expenses paid with tax-free educational assistance such as a scholarship, and an LLC cannot be based on the same expenses used for the tax-free portion of a 529 plan or Coverdell distribution. The Form 8863 instructions also say that some students can choose to include scholarship amounts in income so that more expenses are available for the credit. Whether that makes sense is a tax preparer question.

Who claims the student matters. If a parent claims the student as a dependent, the parent is treated as having paid all of the student's qualified expenses and only the parent can claim a credit for them. If you do not list the student as a dependent, the student may claim the credit. Expenses can be paid by the taxpayer, spouse, the student, or a third party. The Form 8863 instructions state that borrowed money does not matter: expenses paid with a student loan still count, and it does not reduce the expenses available for the credit. Timing matters as well: only expenses paid in 2025 for academic periods beginning in 2025, or in the first three months of 2026, count toward the 2025 credits.

Publication 970 uses the word generally in several places, and it lists exceptions, for example for Form 1098-T. Edge cases such as a student who is a nonresident alien, a student in a foreign school, or one whose scholarships exceed tuition are beyond what a general guide can settle.

How this connects to your college cost plan

Education credits lower a tax bill. They do not change the price on a bill from the school, and they arrive months later, usually as a larger refund or a smaller balance due when the return is filed. In a cost plan, treat the credit as a separate line after the net price, not as a reduction of the published cost. Our guide on sticker price and net price explains why the cost of attendance is not what a family pays, and the credit sits after that calculation.

The credits also interact with how you pay. Because a tax-free scholarship reduces the expenses available for a credit, and a 529 withdrawal used for the same expense cannot be double counted, the order in which you pay for things can change the credit. Our guide on 529 plans versus paying from income covers the savings side. Before the year ends, a tax preparer can look at the specific split of scholarship, 529 and out of pocket money for your family. The numbers in this guide are for 2025, and the IRS publishes new editions for later years, so confirm that the limits have not changed for the year you are filing.

About this guide and its limits

PriceMyDegree is not paid by any school, and there are no sponsored placements and no affiliate links. This guide describes federal rules for the 2025 tax year as printed by the IRS and is general information, not tax advice. We did not review the IRS pages for tax year 2026, state tax credits or deductions, or Canadian education credits. Rules for foreign students and special cases are not covered. Check the current IRS instructions or ask a qualified tax preparer before you file.

Checklist

  1. Collect Form 1098-T from the school for each student and compare it with your own payment records.
  2. List qualified expenses by student: tuition, required fees, and course materials where they count.
  3. Subtract tax-free scholarships and grants from the expenses before calculating a credit.
  4. Check the student's year in school, enrollment level and degree status against the AOTC rules, including the four tax year limit.
  5. Estimate your MAGI and compare it with the $80,000 to $90,000 range ($160,000 to $180,000 joint).
  6. Decide who claims the student as a dependent, since only that person can claim the credit.
  7. Compare the AOTC and the LLC for each student for the year, then complete Form 8863.
  8. Keep receipts and the school's employer identification number for the return.

Common questions

Can I claim both credits in the same year?

You can claim both on one return, but not for the same student and not for the same expenses. Publication 970 says you can use one credit for one student and the other credit for a different student, and it limits the same student to one credit per year.

Which credit is bigger?

The American Opportunity Credit is larger per student, up to $2,500 against up to $2,000 per return for the Lifetime Learning Credit, and up to 40 percent of the AOTC can be refunded. For the same $4,000 of adjusted expenses the AOTC is $2,500 and the LLC is $800 (20 percent of $4,000).

Do student loans count as expenses I paid?

Yes. The Form 8863 instructions say it does not matter whether expenses were paid in cash, by check, by card or with borrowed funds, and payments made with a student loan do not reduce the qualified expenses available for a credit.

My child got a scholarship. Does that matter?

Yes. Expenses paid with tax-free educational assistance such as a scholarship cannot be used to claim a credit, so they reduce the qualified expenses. The instructions also say some students may choose to include scholarship amounts in income to increase the credit, which is a question for a tax preparer.

Who claims the credit if my child is my dependent?

If you claim the student as a dependent, the instructions treat you as having paid the student's qualified expenses, and only you can claim an education credit for them. If you do not claim the student, the student may claim it.

What if my income is above the limit?

For tax year 2025, you cannot claim either credit if MAGI is $90,000 or more ($180,000 or more for joint filers). Between $80,000 and $90,000 ($160,000 to $180,000 joint) the credit is reduced. A single filer at $85,000 gets half of the otherwise allowed credit.

Are these limits the same for next year?

Not necessarily. We read the 2025 editions. The IRS publishes new instructions each year, so check the instructions for the tax year you are filing before you plan around any figure here.